Scrutiny questions Ministers on delivery of strategic priorities
Scrutiny
29 October 2025
A Review Panel has been questioning Ministers about the impact the Government’s Proposed Budget 2026-2029 will have on delivering the 13 Common Strategic Policy priorities committed to during this Government term.The Panel, which is made up of members from the five Scrutiny Panels and the Public Accounts Committee, has been left with concerns about the lack of inter-departmental consultation and leadership at the top.
Following the hearings, the Panel was left with the impression that departments are continuing to work in silos, undermining the effectiveness of funding decisions and risking long-term sustainability.
- The Education and Lifelong Learning Minister admitted he’d not had any discussions with the business community about the choice of 15 hours of free nursery care being funded. The Minister for Sustainable Economic Development said that while he thinks the initiative will hopefully bring more people into the workforce and free up family finances, he is concerned that the government has created a “15 hour situation” when most part time jobs are 20 hours. He added that Government has a habit of not quite matching initiatives with the business environment and that there also hadn’t been any discussion between his department and CYPES over planning skills delivery.
- The Minister for Social Security confirmed only initial conversations have been had between both Ministers to coordinate early years implementation.
- The Minister for the Environment acknowledged that he had misunderstood the implications of agreeing the 13 Common Strategic Priorities, believing it would not affect his ability to deliver his own ministerial priorities within his department’s existing business-as-usual budget. As a result, one of his own top priorities to deliver before the next election, a comprehensive water strategy for the Island, has been put on hold due to the Government’s consultancy freeze.
- The Minister for Health and Social Services confirmed that he has been unable to fulfil his role as Deputy Chief Minister for the past two years due to workload pressures within the Health Department.
However, the Panel did hear examples of successful collaboration. The Minister for Infrastructure said a Sports Ministerial group has been established which has enabled greater community use of school facilities outside of school hours.
Deputy Inna Gardiner, Chair of the Common Strategic Policy Review Panel, said: ‘This silo mentality without a clear leadership structure is very concerning. In a small Island and Government like Jersey, there are no excuses for not ensuring we have a holistic and joined-up approach to setting budgets and agreeing priorities.
‘As a Panel, we are also concerned as to how the balance between delivering a narrowly focused 13 priorities in the short term, is being matched with long-term funding. While reducing the amount we put into the Social Security Fund was supported by all Ministers in the short term, we are concerned about how the initiatives, such as free nursery funding and health, will be financed in the long term if income is not able to cover this cost; and the resulting problem with how public expectations will be managed.
‘We share the concerns of the Minister for Sustainable Economic Development that not investing in the economy creates a risk in maintaining services in health, education and social security in the future. We have to invest in our economy and remove the red tape to allow businesses and Jersey to thrive.
‘We will be putting all these concerns to the Chief Minister and Minister for Treasury and Resources in our public hearings with them on 6 November.’
Other issues discussed:
- The need for potential tax changes was brought up by two Ministers: Minister for Health and Social Services and the Minister for Education and Lifelong Learning. In addition, the Minister for the Environment raised concerns about his department’s falling revenues and the need to increase charges and introduce new ones. This is directly against the Common Strategic Policy priority not to increase fees and charges by more than 2.5% which is under the rate of inflation.
- The Minister for the Environment also warned about further upcoming pressures. With the effects of Brexit there is a need to ensure the Island is set up with laws to make us equivalent to both the UK and EU. There is a huge amount of time needed for law drafters which is going to be expensive.
- The Minister for Health and Social Services said he was very grateful for the money which has been allocated in the proposed budget for health but it is not as much as he would have liked. He also noted that the continuity of care between providers has been hampered by digital inconsistencies and that a single patient record system will improve this.
- The Minister for Education and Lifelong Learning said he would like to see extended education and support up to the age of 25 for those with special needs, but he can’t guarantee it will happen as whilst work is underway it can’t be achieved in this government term. In addition, he said that while he’d like Apprenticeships to become statutory, these are also not likely to be brought in by this current government.
You can watch the Hearings back:
Minister for Health and Social Services
On our website or YouTube
Minister for Social Security and Minister for Education and Lifelong Learning
On our website or YouTube
Minister for the Environment
On our website or YouTube
Minister for Infrastructure
On our website or YouTube
Minister for Sustainable Economic Development
On our website or YouTube
Visit the Review page for further information.
The debate on the Proposed Budget 2026-2029 is scheduled to take place in the States Assembly from Monday 8 December at 9.30am. It is expected to last all week. You can watch:
On our website
On YouTube
On X/Twitter