The official version of this document can be found via the PDF button.
The below content has been automatically generated from the original PDF and some formatting may have been lost, therefore it should not be relied upon to extract citations or propose amendments.
1240/5(6638)
WRITTEN QUESTION TO THE MINISTER FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT
BY DEPUTY M.R. HIGGINS OF ST. HELIER
ANSWER TO BE TABLED ON TUESDAY 17th JANUARY 2012
Question
Will the Minister list in a tabular form the following information in relation to Planning applications which were initially applied for in the years 2005 to 2010 inclusive and which for one reason or another have not yet been determined or withdrawn –
- the date of the initial application;
- the site and nature of the application
- the reason(s) why each application has not been determined or resolved indicating –
- the date(s) and reason the Department sought new information or changed its requirements;
- the date(s) and reasons the applicant has sought voluntarily (ie not at the behest of the Department) to alter their application;
- the date upon which these applications have been reviewed since initially applied for?
Answer
See attached
Answer
Years 2005 - 2010 inclusive
| App No | Address | Description | Valid Date | Why not determined? including date and reason Dept sought info/changes or date and reason applicant supplied new info/changes | Date last review |
1 | P/2006/0636 | St Juste, Merton Hotel, Belvedere Hill, St Saviour | Demolish existing staff accommodation and construct indoor bowling hall with associated landscaping works. AMENDED PLANS: Minor material and design alterations. FURTHER AMENDED: Demolish modern extensions to 'St. Juste' and replace roof with thatch. Construct indoor bowling alley and associated landscaping. Erect tensile roof over existing tennis court for multi-purpose ball court. FURTHER AMENDED PLANS: Demolish structure to north/east of site & modern extensions to 'St. Juste'; removal of three external support walls to east elevation of 'St. Juste'; replace roof with thatch. Construct indoor bowling alley to north/east of 'St. Juste'; associated landscaping. Erect tensile roof over existing tennis court for multi-purpose ball court. | 05/04/2006 | Minister resolved to approve the application in November 2009. Since that time the conclusion has been awaiting the applicants completion of a Planning Obligation Agreement (see also P/2007/1427). | Weekly |
2 | PP/2006/2444 | 80-92 Bath Street, The Former Odeon Cinema and 14-28 James Street, St Helier | Refurbishment & regeneration of the former Odeon cinema to form retail unit. Construct retail unit adjacent to cinema on basement & ground floor & multi storey carpark on first to fourth floor. Extensive hard landscaping and external works including enclosed service yard and plant compound. REVISED PLANS: Former Odeon Cinema removed from the scheme. Transport assessment and supplementary retail impact assessment submitted. Food store car park reduced in height. | 09/11/2006 | Application is missing some key information, with the conclusion linked to the North of Town Masterplan (approved by the States in June 2011). The applicant has requested the scheme is held while they consider their options. Last correspondence in October 2011. | Weekly |
3 | P/2006/2562 | Thorp House, Broadcasting House & Summerland | Construct new 4 storey Police Headquarters & refurbish existing facilities within Summerland. Provide 3.6m High Perimeter fencing/screening and improve existing parking. Alter vehicular access. | 24/11/2006 | States of Jersey application – progression is linked to the conclusion of the wider Police HQ strategy. | Weekly |
4 | RP/2007/0471 | Holme Growne, Fauvic Nurseries, La Rue au Long, Grouville | Replace existing glasshouse over existing sales area. Increase sales area & form cafe area. Demolish glasshouse to provide parking. Alterations to vehicle access. REVISED PLANS: RETROSPECTIVE: Revised layout and reduction in the size of the approved cafe. | 26/02/2007 | Applicant has been asked to withdraw this application, as the works have been superseded by P/2009/0267 (approved 21/01/2011). Conclusion is pending outcome of P/2009/0647 (see below). | n/a |
5 | P/2007/1001 | La Hougue Farm, La Grande Route de St Pierre, St Peter | Construct play barn and reconfiguration of previously approved office and shop entrance. | 30/04/2007 | Additional information from applicant requested September 2010 | Monthly |
6 | P/2007/1427 | La Fantaisie, Merton Hotel, Belvedere Hill, St Saviour | Refurbish existing building into 6 No. staff apartments. | 14/06/2007 | Minister resolved to approve the application in November 2009. Since that time the conclusion has been awaiting the applicant | Weekly |
|
|
|
|
| completing a Planning Obligation Agreement (see also P/2006/0636) |
|
7 | P/2007/2945 | Le Port Carpark, La Grande Route des Mielles, St Peter | Permanent trading licence for a concession on the site. Construction of new man made dune over subterranean stores and toilet with indigenous landscape to top surface. | 10/12/2007 | Application superseded by renewal of existing temporary consent. Awaiting formal withdrawal. | Monthly |
8 | RC/2007/2971 | Land at La Collette Reclaimation Site, La Rue D'Auvergne, St Helier | Vary condition 5 of permit P/2002/2597 so that the temporary timber and green waste recycling facility can continue to operate until a new composting facility is fully operational. | 11/02/2007 | Awaiting information from TTS as applicant on operational issues (March 2011) | Weekly |
9 | P/2008/1681 | Esplanade Quarter, Esplanade, St Helier | Excavation and enabling works to form basement car park, new underground road tunnel and other associated road works and general infrastructural works. | 04/08/2008 | (Below ground works). Determination is deferred pending conclusion of wider context of Esplanade Quarter project. | Monthly |
10 | P/2008/2666 | Le Petit Menage, Belvedere Hill, St Saviour | Form hardstanding to create temporary staff car parking area to serve nursery | 30/12/2008 | Revised proposal following refusal of P/2007/1927. Scope for compromise being considered, further pre-application proposals submitted by applicant in November 2011. In current dialogue. | Weekly |
11 | P/2009/0647 | Holme Growne, Fauvic Nurseries, La Rue au Long, Grouville | RETROSPECTIVE: Create garden centre. | 24/03/2009 | On next agenda for next Ministerial Meeting, was held pending conclusion of Royal Court appeal on parallel application P/2009/0267 (see also RP/2007/0471) | Weekly |
12 | P/2009/2073 | Fields 733,734,735,737,738,739,740, 740a,744a & 744b, Radier Manor, Le Chemin de Radier, Grouville | AMENDED PLANS: Proposed Change of use of land and other landscape works to create Botanical Gardens and Parkland with sculpture displays, erection of marquees for weddings & functions, inclusive of car park, tearoom, shop, and toilet facilities. Re-align access from 'La Vier Mont' and alter position of ' Grouville ' mileage stone. RETROSPECTIVE: Excavation & levelling of main lawn to south/west, of Manor. Field 739 - creation of car park, removal of shale for internal road access/repairs, & creation of new road access utilising existing track. Demolish existing garage to 'La Rochelle' to realign existing driveway, and general landscaping. | 09/11/2009 | Planning Panel meeting of December 2011 deferred their decision pending additional information from applicant, who suggested application was to be altered application was to be progressed in whole, or in part. Awaiting response from applicant. | Weekly |
13 | P/2009/2108 | Plemont Bay Holiday Village, La Route de Plemont, St Ouen | Demolish existing buildings. Construct 28 new and 2 replacement dwellings. Return two thirds of site to nature. Refurbish WWII Bunker with associated landscaping and footpaths. AMENDED DESCRIPTION: Revised site boundary removing approx 5,750 sq.m from the application site, primarily along the Northern edge of the site. Reduction in numbers of proposed dwellings from 30 to 28. Minor revisions to detailed design and layout. Footpath link from the site to the North coast cliff path. | 16/11/2009 | Application put on hold pending resolution of ownership issue. Fresh planning application submitted in order to resolve the issue 22/12/2012. | Weekly |
14 | P/2009/2137 | Jersey Mushroom Tunnels, La Route de L'Aleval, St Peter | Change of use of part of mushroom tunnels for storage of landscaping materials. | 19/11/2009 | Retrospective application. Applicant occupies part of the tunnel complex. Details of use do not appear acceptable and Department has become aware of other users within the complex. | Monthly |
|
|
|
|
| Department has been liaising with the applicant and owner to resolve a way forward. |
|
15 | P/2009/2253 | Tamaris, La Grande Route de St Clement, St Clement | Demolish existing dwelling. Construct 4 No. apartments. AMENDED PLANS RECEIVED. | 09/12/2009 | Considerable planning history, and significant design concerns to original proposals, confirmed by Planning Panel. Revised proposal on agenda of January 2012 Planning Panel meeting. | Weekly |
16 | P/2009/2419 | Field 91A, Belle Vue, La Route des Quennevais, St Brelade | Residential Development. AMENDED PLANS: Amended design and layout incorporating 20 houses and 35 apartments. | 06/01/2010 | Original application was not considered acceptable and negotiations have continued since. New scheme submitted November 2011. | Weekly |
17 | RP/2010/0174 | 15-16 The Parade, St Helier | Demolish existing buildings and construct new 3 1/2 storey medical practice with ground floor retail dispense pharmacy. REVISED PLANS: Construct various extensions and external alterations. | 15/02/2010 | Minister resolved to approve the application in June 2010. Since that time the conclusion has been awaiting the applicant completing a Planning Obligation Agreement. | Monthly |
18 | P/2010/0212 | Les Charrieres Hotel, Les Charrieres, St Peter | Demolish existing hotel. Construct 10 No. dwellings. Model available. | 22/02/2010 | Original scheme not considered acceptable and negotiations have continued since. | Monthly |
19 | RP/2010/0310 | Fleurs de Rocaille, Longville Avenue ,St Brelade | Demolish existing dwelling. Construct replacement 4 bedroom dwelling. REVISED PLANS: Demolish existing dwelling and construct 5 No. bedroom dwelling with revised floor plan. Minor fenestration alterations. | 11/03/2010 | Application considered unacceptable but Minister application held open for an alternative scheme. Discussions continuing. | Monthly |
20 | P/2010/0752 | Crows Nest, Mont les Vaux, St Brelade | Excavation and engineering works to create new vehicular access. | 24/05/2010 | Application involves complex geotechnical issues. A geo technical report was requested on 4/8/2010 and one was not submitted until a year later on 5/8/2011. This report was forwarded to T&TS engineers for comment and the application is | Weekly |
|
|
|
|
| now likely to be taken to the next available PAP meeting. |
|
21 | P/2010/0767 | Municipal Services Depot, La Grande Route de St Jean, St Helier | Erect parish recycling centre and workshops. EIA Submitted. | 26/05/2010 | Supplier not able to deliver original building, applicant (Parish of St Helier) requested proposal be held whilst they confirmed their options (July 2010), revised plans received October 2011, and readvertised, live application. | Weekly |
22 | P/2010/0896 | McQuaigs Quarry, Les Charrieres de Bonne Nuit, St John | RETROSPECTIVE: Use part of site for the storage and sorting of mixed skip loads before onward recycling. | 16/06/2010 | Additional information requested from applicant initially 17 January 2011. | Weekly |
23 | P/2010/0917 | The Flat, Home Farm, La Rue de Grouville , Grouville | Demolish existing residential unit. Construct 1 No. dwelling. AMENDED PLANS RECEIVED. | 18/06/2010 | Detailed design issues as part of Listed group of wider redevelopment site, with extensive planning history. Ready to be concluded, delegated to officers, decision imminent. | Weekly |
24 | P/2010/1124 | 8-9 Esplanade, 10-12 Commercial Street, St Helier | Demolish existing buildings. Construct 5 storey office, with basement parking. Retain PSSI on Commercial Street and BLI facade of Howard House on The Esplanade. Model Available. AMENDED PLANS RECEIVED. | 02/08/2010 | Awaiting publication of Esplanade Design Guidance (Feb 2012) seeking a consistent and transparent framework of policy for several development proposals on the Esplanade. | Weekly |
25 | P/2010/1255 | Century House, Le Canibut, St John | RETROSPECTIVE: Construct aviaries to the South-East of main dwelling. | 23/08/2010 | Held open for submission of Noise Reports following a deferral by the Planning Panel in March 2011. These were received in December 2011 and are currently been assessed before the application can be reported back to the planning Panel. | Weekly |
26 | RP/2010/1359 | Beau Couperon Hotel, Le Mont de Rozel, St Martin | Demolish existing hotel and restaurant, retaining registered walls. Construct 10 No. apartments with basement parking. REVISED PLANS: Raise part of roof to Unit 1. AMENDED DESCRIPTION, REVISED PLANS: Raise part of roof to Unit 5. | 09/09/2010 | Alternative scheme discussed with the applicant. Confirmation of agreement awaited. Work has stopped on site for reasons not connected with this. | Monthly |
27 | P/2010/1422 | Former Cleveland Garage & Heather Lea, | Demolish existing garage and dwelling. Construct 16 No. dwellings with basement parking. Re-locate JEC substation. (Model Available). AMENDED PLANS (REVISED DESIGN): Demolish existing garage and dwelling. Construct 15 No. dwellings with basement parking. Relocate JEC substation. | 22/09/2010 | Awaiting information from applicant in relation to policies from new Island Plan (chased 6 Jan 2012) | Weekly |
28 | RC/2010/1683 | La Vignette Bungalow, La Rue de la Vignette, St Martin | Removal of corpus fundi condition from permit 5342/B. | 16/11/2010 | Applicant requested agricultural workers condition also be considered for which additional information was required. This has been submitted and decision will be issued shortly. | Weekly |
29 | P/2010/1717 | Field 622,La Clos de la Croute, St Ouen | Construct 19 No. sheltered accommodation units, communal building and new vehicular access. (Model Available). | 23/11/2010 | Held open at the request of the applicant (Parish) who wish to seek an amendment to the Island Plan. | Monthly |
30 | P/2010/1729 | States of Jersey Airport, St Peter | Demolish existing arrivals and baggage hall. | 25/11/2010 | Aspirations of CAA and the Minister to be weighed up before the demolition of a Listed Building can be considered fully. Ongoing work on site to remove recent additions to the building, have a separate approval. | Monthly |
31 | P/2010/1804 | Le Marais Farm, La Rue Coentyn, St Ouen | Re-roof main house and outbuildings to a slightly raised height. Reform cement render verges and drippers. | 08/12/2010 | Information requested from applicant. | Monthly |
32 | P/2010/1861 | Cell 30, La Collette Reclamation, La Collette, St Helier | Construction and operation of cell for disposal of asbestos waste. EIA Submitted. | 17/12/2010 | Awaiting information from TTS as applicant in relation to technical asbestos issues (June 2011) | Weekly |
33 | P/2010/1865 | White Doves, Park Estate, St Brelade | Demolish existing dwelling. Construct 1 No. dwelling. AMENDED PLANS: Various alterations including new central tower. | 21/12/2012 | Following submission of amended plans scheme is due to be put to the PAP. | Weekly |
34 | P/2010/1869 | Condor Logistics, La Route du Port, St Helier | Steel framed pitched roof enclosure over existing external unloading yard. | 21/12/2010 | Significant design concerns expressed since submission. Revised plans received from applicant on 20 December 2011. | Weekly |