This content has been automatically generated from the original PDF and some formatting may have been lost. Let us know if you find any major problems.
Text in this format is not official and should not be relied upon to extract citations or propose amendments. Please see the PDF for the official version of the document.
Economic Affairs Scrutiny Sub-Panel (Telecoms Privatisation)
PUBLIC MEETING Record of Meeting
Date: 28th November 2007 Meeting Number: 17
Present | Deputy G. P. Southern , Chairman Deputy J.G. Reed Deputy J. A. Martin |
Apologies | Deputy G.C.L. Baudains |
Absent |
|
In attendance | Mrs. E. Kingston-Walsh, Scrutiny Officer |
Ref Back | Agenda matter | Action |
1. | Minutes th The Sub Panel approved the minutes of the meeting dated 14 November 2007. |
|
2. | Matters arising The Sub-Panel recalled a paper by Professor Massimo Florio entitled Telecom Italia 1997-2007: A case study in Privatisation Failures'. The Chairman advised the Sub-Panel that the legal advisors were unable to respond before 17th December 2007. He further advised that he had been informed by Professor Parker that the examples given in Annex 5.4 of P.153/2007 were not typical examples and that it would be unwise to rely upon conclusions drawn from them. The Chairman informed the Sub-Panel that he had been informed of the Unite' Trade Union's intention to campaign against the sale of Jersey Telecom. The officer was directed to establish the current pension package offered by Jersey Telecom. | EKW |
3. | Amendment The Sub-Panel considered the amendment to P.153/2007 proposed by Senator B. Shenton. The officer was directed to establish the implications of removing table two from the proposition. | EKW |
4. | Advice request of Professor David Parker The Sub-Panel considered the response from David Parker and noted that the response had been sent to the legal advisors. The Sub-Panel approved the invoice from Professor Parker for a sum of £325. The Officer was directed to take the appropriate action. | EKW |
5. | Protection of the Island's Skill Base The Sub-Panel recalled their concern of the future of the Island's skills and training base following the privatisation of Jersey Telecom. It further recalled that new mobile operators appeared to use off-island engineering staff from the parent company when required. The Sub-Panel agreed that it would request further information regarding the composition of Telecoms workforce from the Economic Development Minister. The Officer was directed to take the appropriate action. | EKW |
6. | Oral Questions The Sub-Panel considered oral questions for the next States Assembly. |
|
7. | Number Portability The Sub-Panel recalled that the number portability issue was still outstanding and noted concern regarding the powers of the Jersey Competition Regulatory Authority (JCRA). It questioned how the JCRA would cope with a multi-national company considering the difficulties and costs faced in regulating a States owned utility. |
|
| Future Meetings The Sub-Panel agreed that it should meet on the 12th and 19th December 2007 to consider and finalise the Sub-Panel's comment to P.153/2007. The Officer was directed to request the legal advice by the 12th December 2007. The Chairman agreed to arrange an informal meeting with Mr P. Funk from Newtel Solutions. |
|
Signed Date: ..
Chairman
Economic Affairs Scrutiny Sub-Panel (Telecoms Privatisation)