Skip to main content

Health, Social Security and Housing - Approved Panel Minutes - 24 May 2013

The official version of this document can be found via the PDF button.

The below content has been automatically generated from the original PDF and some formatting may have been lost, therefore it should not be relied upon to extract citations or propose amendments.

Health, Social Security and Housing Scrutiny Panel

Record of Meeting

Date: 24th May 2013 Meeting No: 109

 

Present

Deputy K. L. Moore , Chairman Deputy J. A. Hilton, Vice-Chairman Deputy J. G. Reed

Apologies

 

Absent

 

In attendance

Miss K. Boydens , Scrutiny Officer Mrs F. Scott , Scrutiny Officer

 

Ref Back

Agenda matter

Action

 

1.  Records of Meetings

The Panel noted and approved the records of its meetings held on the 2nd, 3rd and 10th May 2013. The Chairman thereby signed the records accordingly.

 

23.05.13 Item 1

517/21

2.  Full  Business  Case  Review:  Redesign  of  Health  and  Social Services

The Panel discussed its FBC review and agreed that progress was being made. It noted that, as the FBCs had not been completed, it would continue with its review and await receipt of the documents. The Panel also agreed that as the Health Department had been making more positive progress with the FBC process, it may not present a full report into the matter and a statement may suffice. This matter would be discussed further in due course.

The Panel requested a meeting Dr. N. Minihane, Dr. P. Venn and Dr. Z. Cameron,  members  of  the  Primary  Care  Body  to  discuss  the sustainable primary care funding mechanism.

KB

13.12.11 Item 10

517/1(36)

3.  Future Reviews

The  Panel  discussed  its  future  work  and  agreed  that  the  following should be reviewed: Long-Term Care Law, Regulation of Care Law, Regulation  of  Social  Housing,  Public  Health  and  Safety  (Dwellings) (Jersey) Law 201-, Mental Health (Jersey) Law 1969, Respite Care for older adults and the "new" Hospital.

The Panel agreed that the Long-Term Care Law was a priority and would be discussed in detail after it had received a briefing from the Minister for Social Security. The Panel also agreed that even though the Regulation  of  Care  Law,  Regulation  of  Social  Housing  and  Public Health and Safety (Dwellings) (Jersey) Law 201- would require work, it was not thought that a substantial amount of time would need to be dedicated to these.

A brief discussion into the Regulation of Care Law followed, and the Panel requested a briefing with the Department and Ms. C. Blackwood, Registration  and  Inspection  Manager  to  discuss  what  was  being proposed and the timeline.

KB/FS

 

The Panel agreed that questions regarding mental health should be added  to  the  question  plan  for  the  next  quarterly  hearing  with  the Minister for Health and Social Services.

KB/FS

517/23

4.  Hospital Review Sub-Panel

The Panel recalled its decision to review the "new" hospital build. It agreed that a Sub-Panel should be established and requested that Members of the Corporate Services Scrutiny Panel were invited to sit on the Sub-Panel.

KB/FS

19.04.13 Item 6

517/1(49)

5.  Jersey Consumer Council

The  Panel  met  with  Advocate  R.  Colley,  Chairman  of  the  Jersey Consumer Council, Ms A. King, Jersey Consumer Council (JCC) Officer and Dr S. Arun to discuss its Primary Health Care report.

The Panel heard that the report had been positively received and that a meeting was scheduled with the Primary Healthcare Body on 24th June to discuss the recommendations contained in the report. In particular recommendations around transparency over pricing for patients had been  well  received  and  were  already  being  implemented  by  some surgeries and practices.

Following  the  meeting  with  the  primary  healthcare  body  a  public meeting was to be held to discuss feedback and to decide the next steps for the JCC.

The Panel suggested that conducting a subsequent report on acute services in a similar vein to the present report would be welcome. The Chairman of the JCC told the Panel that the next planned review for 2013 would focus on transport, but that there could be a follow-up healthcare review in 2014 depending on resources. The bid for the next review was due in September 2013 and the JCC agreed to take into account the Panel's preferences.

The Panel encouraged the representatives to write to the Health and Social Services Department enclosing the recommendations and asking for a formal response. The representatives agreed to this and to copy to Panel in to communications.

The JCC Officer told the Panel that some of the questions from the report would be re-run in the Jersey Annual Social Survey (JASS) to enable more conclusive data to be gathered. It was her opinion that more focus groups were required as a part of the re-design of health services in order to bring some of the more esoteric concepts to the public and to gauge their opinions face-to-face. The Panel agreed this was critical to ensure that the new healthcare system reflected the needs of the public.

 

01.03.13 Item 3

517/1(25)

6.  Quarterly Public Hearing with the Minister for Social Security

The  Panel  discussed  its  questions  in  preparation  for  the  quarterly hearing with the Minister for Social Security.

The Panel received Senator F. du H. Le Gresley, Minister for Social Security, Deputy S. Pinel, Assistant Minister for Social Security, Mrs S. Duhamel,  Policy  and  Strategy  Director,  Mr  I.  Burns,  Operations Director, and Mr J. Williams, Director of Contributions, Enforcement and Contributory Benefits for a Quarterly Public Hearing.

 

12.04.13 Item 2

517/1(25)

7.  Quarterly Public Hearing with the Minister for Health and Social Services

The Panel noted that it was scheduled to hold a quarterly hearing with the Minister for Health and Social Services on the 28th June 2013. The Panel was advised that the Minister was unable to attend on the 28th June and agreed that an alternative date should be identified.

KB/FS

14.09.12 Item 1

517/1(25)

8.  Long-Term  Care  Law:  Meeting  with  the  Minister  for  Social Security

The Panel met with Senator F. du H Le Gresley, Minister for Social Security, Deputy S. Pinel, Assistant Minister for Social Security, Mrs S. Duhamel, Policy and Strategy Director and Mr J. Williams, Director of CECB to discuss the Long-Term Care Law. This meeting was held in private under Article 3.2.1(a)(xiv) of the Code of Practice on Public Access to Official Information.

 

 

9.  Future Meetings

The Panel noted that its next scheduled meeting would take place on the 14th June 2013 in the Le Capelain room, States Building.